Kirk of Reasons Unbeknownst ping-backed my post on intelligent design, so I figured I’d do him the same courtesy in my reply. (Is that considered a courtesy? I don’t know. I’m only blogging to see my own writing.) He also mirrored part of the post in the comments. Anyway, here’s what he had to say.
Great points until you get into economics. The intellectuals with Ph.Ds in econ tend to think Socialism is a great idea. The god fearing masses may be wrong about darwin but their low-tax instincts are a good thing. In other words it could be worse, we could be a nation of atheists that think Marx was on to something. Ideally we’d be pro separation of Church/State and anti-Socialist but that’s a hell of a lot to ask people who don’t want to live without either a big friendly god or a big friendly brother. Though I wonder if big governments see religion as competition (tithings vs. taxes) and subtly discourage religion, though China unsubtly encarcerates Falun Gongers.
Kirk, you’ve got this apparent dichotomy of “It’s either small government or it’s a bunch of fucking commies”. Like lots of things in life, there is a happy medium between social and personal responsibility. Like it or not, we do live with other people who we have an unwritten contract with, and we, as a society, do have obligations to each other. You can have social policy without being a communist government. You’re also making the mistake of equating big social governments and big economic governments. They are not the same, and in fact, one can be big while the other can be small.
The neo-con invasion of the Republican party should have made this clear. Under Saint Ronald and now George W. Bush, the federal government’s social influence in the everyday lives of its citizens increased substantially. One of Reagan’s worst policy initiatives was giving the FCC the power to curb free speech on public airwaves, and Bush is making it clear that he wants the power to poke his nose into Americans’ homes, phone calls and private communications whenever it suits him, without any court review at all. While he was busy peeking under our sheets, Bush and his neo-con buddies have shot through legislation that basically lets corporations run roughshod over the consumer. Because hey, the Invisible Hand will always be there to protect the consumer’s interests, right? Sorry, I don’t think so. When you have little or no government regulation over the free market, you get monopolies like Microsoft and cartels like the RIAA and MPAA. Oh yeah, and the oil and pharmaceutical companies get to ram a government-subsidized screwdriver up the American people’s ass.
The Republican party got into bed with the Christian right, so I hardly think that churches are considered “competition” by our glorious leaders. No, churches are for harvesting voters. The problem is that the Christian right doesn’t realize that. They think the Republican party actually gives a shit about their agenda at some time other than an election year. Once the likes of Pat Robertson realize that the Republicans will never deliver on their promises to end abortion and amend the Constitution to outlaw gay marriage (otherwise what would they use to get the bigoted masses to the polls?), they’ll stay their asses home on election day. And that day can’t come soon enough.